# 2025-12230: Coal Mine Roof Plans Get Another Round of Rulebook Housekeeping

2025-12230, Roof Control Plan Approval Criteria, is a Federal Register proposed rule from Labor Department, Mine Safety and Health Administration published 2025-07-01, effective Comments must be received on or before July 31, 2025.; PRIA reads it as touching household money (as of 2026-11-09).

- Canonical: https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2025-12230
- As of: 2026-11-09
- Plain-text twin of the page above; the HTML and this file carry the same facts.

## Facts
- Document number: 2025-12230
- Title: Roof Control Plan Approval Criteria
- Type: Proposed Rule
- Agencies: Labor Department; Mine Safety and Health Administration
- Citation: 90 FR 28432
- Published: 2025-07-01
- Effective: Comments must be received on or before July 31, 2025.
- Comments close: not stated
- Significant: no
- Touches household money: yes
- Regulation identifier numbers: 1219-AC18
- Last updated: 2026-11-09

## In one line

Coal Mine Roof Plans Get Another Round of Rulebook Housekeeping

## Summary

MSHA wants to change the rules about roof control plans in coal mines by removing the power of District Managers to add extra requirements. This update makes sure the rules follow the law and proper procedures. Mine operators should get ready to comment by July 31, 2025, but no new costs are expected right now.

## Abstract

MSHA is proposing to revise its roof control plan regulations to eliminate the provision that allows the District Manager to require additional measures to be included in plans. The current regulation may violate statutory authority; the Appointments Clause, by vesting significant regulatory authority in District Managers; and the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), by skipping notice and comment.

## Effects PRIA read

- District Manager may no longer add plan rules: benefit, low. If you operate an underground coal mine, MSHA proposes to remove the rule that lets the District Manager require additional, unspecified measures in roof control plans. The change would align plan requirements strictly with 30 CFR 75.220–75.223 and remove the sentence that currently says "Additiona…
- Estimated direct cost savings to operators: benefit, medium. MSHA estimates operators would avoid annual labor costs of $108,355 from not making District Manager‑requested plan revisions, plus $1,698 in annual copying and mailing savings. MSHA reports total undiscounted savings of $1.1 million over 10 years and an annualized cost saving of $110,053.
- Paperwork and review burden reduced: benefit, medium. MSHA estimates fewer submissions and lower burden hours: new roof control plans dropping from 84 to 42 annually, revised plans from 482 to 241, a total reduction of 283 submissions, and a reduction of 1,468 annual burden hours. MSHA also estimates annual recordkeeping cost savings of $1,698.
- No significant economic impact on small mines: benefit, low. MSHA used SBA size thresholds and estimated 115 underground coal mines qualify as small. MSHA finds the rule's annualized costs for small mines are $0.11 million versus estimated small‑mine revenues of $5.1 billion, a ratio of 0.002 percent, and certifies the rule would not have a significant econo…
- Potential increase in predictable coal production: benefit, low. MSHA states a potential benefit is increased domestic energy production because more predictable and faster plan approvals may allow mines to optimize coal output. MSHA lists this as a qualitative benefit of the proposed rule.

## Related documents

- [2026-15717](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2026-15717): Ventilation Plan Approval Criteria, 2026-08-03
- [2026-15670](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2026-15670): Roof Control Plan Approval Criteria, 2026-08-03
- [2026-10456](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2026-10456): Department of Labor Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act Annual Adjustments for 2026, 2026-05-27
- [2025-12232](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2025-12232): Ventilation Plan Approval Criteria, 2025-07-01
- [2026-21213](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2026-21213): Affirmative Decisions on Petitions for Modification Granted in Whole or in Part, 2026-10-16
- [2026-21175](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2026-21175): Petition for Modification of Application of Existing Mandatory Safety Standards, 2026-10-16

## Sources
- [2025-12230 on federalregister.gov](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2025/07/01/2025-12230/roof-control-plan-approval-criteria)
- [2025-12230 as published (PDF)](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2025-07-01/pdf/2025-12230.pdf)

## Related
- [Previous: 2025-12194, Retiring Form FRA F 6180.107 and Form FRA F 6180.150](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2025-12194)
- [Next: 2025-12231, Training and Retraining of Miners](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2025-12231)
- [All Federal Register documents](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register)

Source: PRIA, https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2025-12230 (as of 2026-11-09).
