# 2025-21441: Court Tosses Mining Water Filters, Sparking Eco-Debate

2025-21441, Rescission of Portions of Permanent Program Performance Standards Related to Siltation Structures, is a Federal Register rule from Interior Department, Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement Office published 2025-11-28, effective 2026-01-27 (as of 2026-06-11).

- Canonical: https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2025-21441
- As of: 2026-06-11
- Plain-text twin of the page above; the HTML and this file carry the same facts.

## Facts
- Document number: 2025-21441
- Title: Rescission of Portions of Permanent Program Performance Standards Related to Siltation Structures
- Type: Rule
- Agencies: Interior Department; Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement Office
- Citation: 90 FR 54575
- Published: 2025-11-28
- Effective: 2026-01-27
- Comments close: not stated
- Significant: no
- Touches household money: no
- Regulation identifier numbers: 1029-AC92
- Last updated: 2026-06-11

## In one line

Court Tosses Mining Water Filters, Sparking Eco-Debate

## Summary

Starting January 27, 2026, new rules will remove the requirement that all water runoff from mining sites must pass through siltation structures. This change affects mining companies regulated by the Office of Surface Mining and is a response to a court decision that said the old rule wasn’t backed up well enough. No extra costs are expected, but the public can comment until December 29, 2025, before the rule takes effect.

## Abstract

This direct final rule revises the Federal regulations to remove paragraphs that required that all surface drainage from the disturbed area pass through a siltation structure before leaving the permit area. These paragraphs were struck down on judicial review because the court found that the Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement (OSMRE) had not articulated a sufficient basis for the rule under the Administrative Procedure Act and that OSMRE had not sufficiently demonstrated that siltation structures were the best technology currently available.

## Effects PRIA read

- Siltation-Structure Requirement Removed: benefit, low. Starting January 27, 2026, the rule removes the parts of 30 CFR 816.46 and 817.46 that required all surface drainage from a disturbed mining area to pass through a siltation structure before leaving the permit area. The change explicitly affects mining companies regulated by the Office of Surface M…
- Best-Technology Requirement Still Applies: mixed, low. The rule leaves paragraph (b)(1) in 30 CFR 816.46 and 817.46, which continues to require use of the "best technology currently available" to prevent additional suspended solids in runoff. That paragraph may still require siltation structures in specific cases where they are the best technology.

## Related documents

- [2025-21443](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2025-21443): Rescission of Fee Rates, 2025-11-28
- [2026-21726](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2026-21726): Agency Information Collection Activities; 30 CFR 822-Special Permanent Program Performance Standards-Operations in Alluvial Valley Floors, 2026-10-26
- [2026-21835](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2026-21835): Wyoming Regulatory Program, 2026-10-26
- [2026-21807](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2026-21807): Ohio Regulatory Program, 2026-10-26
- [2026-17821](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2026-17821): Montana Regulatory Program, 2026-09-01
- [2026-17333](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2026-17333): Montana Regulatory Program, 2026-08-25

## Sources
- [2025-21441 on federalregister.gov](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2025/11/28/2025-21441/rescission-of-portions-of-permanent-program-performance-standards-related-to-siltation-structures)
- [2025-21441 as published (PDF)](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2025-11-28/pdf/2025-21441.pdf)

## Related
- [Previous: 2025-21440, Backfilling and Grading](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2025-21440)
- [Next: 2025-21442, Certification and Noncoal Reclamation](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2025-21442)
- [All Federal Register documents](https://policyrisk.com/federal-register)

Source: PRIA, https://policyrisk.com/federal-register/2025-21441 (as of 2026-06-11).
