# Federal Threat Crimes — Threatening the President, Interstate Threats & Threatening Communications

It is a federal crime to threaten the President of the United States, to send threatening messages across state lines or through the mail, or to threaten former Presidents, their families, major presi

- Canonical: https://policyrisk.com/wiki/federal-threat-crimes
- As of: 2026-11-15
- Plain-text twin of the page above; the HTML and this file carry the same facts.

## Facts
- Domain: criminal-justice
- Category: Criminal Justice
- Page type: topic
- U.S. Code anchor: none
- Last verified: not recorded

## Article

It is a federal crime to threaten the President of the United States, to send threatening messages across state lines or through the mail, or to threaten former Presidents, their families, major presidential candidates, and other Secret Service protectees. These statutes — clustered in 18 U.S.C. §§ 871–880 — cover an enormous range of conduct in the digital age, from social media posts and text messages to letters mailed to the White House. What makes them constitutionally distinct from ordinary political speech is the Supreme Court's "true threat" doctrine: a statement is a true threat only if a reasonable person would interpret it as a serious expression of intent to commit violence, not merely rhetoric, hyperbole, or political frustration. But that line can be harder to find in practice than in theory — and crossing it results in felony prosecution.

## Current Law (2026)

| Statute | Prohibition | Maximum Penalty |
|---------|-------------|-----------------|
| 18 U.S.C. § 871 | Threatening the President, Vice President, President-elect, or successor in line | 5 years |
| 18 U.S.C. § 875(b) | Interstate ransom demands for kidnapped persons | 20 years |
| 18 U.S.C. § 875(c) | Interstate threat to kidnap or injure | 5 years |
| 18 U.S.C. § 875(d) | Interstate extortion by threat to property or reputation | 2 years |
| 18 U.S.C. § 876(b) | Mailing ransom demands | 20 years |
| 18 U.S.C. § 876(c) | Mailing threats to kidnap or injure | 5 years (10 years if target is judge or federal officer) |
| 18 U.S.C. § 878 | Threats against foreign officials or internationally protected persons | 5 years; 20 years if connected to extortion |
| 18 U.S.C. § 879 | Threats against former Presidents, their families, major candidates, and Secret Service protectees | 5 years |
| 18 U.S.C. § 880 | Receiving proceeds of extortion | 3 years |

## Legal Authority

- **18 U.S.C. § 871 — Threats Against the President**: The oldest and best-known threat statute, making it a federal felony to knowingly and willfully threaten to kill, kidnap, or inflict bodily harm on the President, President-elect, Vice President, Vice President-elect, or the officer next in the presidential line of succession. "Knowingly and willfully" means the defendant must have known the statement would be perceived as a threat — idle or joking remarks, clearly ironic political commentary, and artistic expression can fall outside the statute.

- **18 U.S.C. § 875 — Interstate Communications**: Targets threats transmitted through any channel of interstate or foreign commerce — phone calls, emails, texts, social media, or messaging apps. Where the threat involves unauthorized computer access, the [Computer Fraud and Abuse Act](computer-fraud-abuse-act.md) often layers on top. The reach is broad: any electronic communication that crosses state lines qualifies. The statute covers both threats to injure (§ 875(c), 5 years) and extortionate threats connecting injury to a demand for money or value (§ 875(b), 20 years). Courts have held that social media posts directed at specific individuals can qualify even without direct transmission to the victim.

- **18 U.S.C. § 876 — Mailing Threatening Communications**: Covers threatening letters, packages, and electronic communications that pass through the U.S. Postal Service or that are deposited in the mail. Raises the penalty to 10 years (from the standard 5) when the target is a federal judge, a federal law enforcement officer, or any other federally protected official. The statute applies even when the sender is anonymous.

- **18 U.S.C. § 878 — Threats Against Foreign Officials and Internationally Protected Persons**: Covers threats against foreign government officials, diplomatic personnel, and individuals who receive special international protection (e.g., heads of state visiting the U.S., UN officials). The U.S. can prosecute under this section even when the threatened person is outside the United States, as long as the offender is a U.S. national or the offender is later found in the U.S.

- **18 U.S.C. § 879 — Threats Against Former Presidents and Others**: Extends § 871's coverage to former Presidents and their immediate families (spouses and children under 16), the immediate families of current Presidents and Vice Presidents, major presidential and vice-presidential candidates and their families, and anyone under Secret Service protection. "Major candidate" has the meaning given under 18 U.S.C. § 3056 — generally candidates who have qualified for federal matching funds or are otherwise formally recognized.

- **18 U.S.C. § 880 — Receiving Proceeds of Extortion**: Targets those who knowingly accept money or property that resulted from extortion offenses in Chapter 41. For the broader federal extortion framework, see [Hobbs Act](hobbs-act-extortion-robbery.md) (the chapter containing these threat statutes). Up to 3 years. This closes the loop on extortion schemes where the person receiving the payment is different from the one making the threat.

## The "True Threat" Doctrine and the First Amendment

Threat statutes sit at the intersection of criminal law and the First Amendment. The Supreme Court has held that "true threats" — statements where the speaker means to communicate a serious intent to commit unlawful violence — are not protected speech. But political hyperbole, satire, and angry rhetoric are protected.

The Court's 2023 decision in **Counterman v. Colorado** clarified the constitutional mens rea requirement: the government must prove at minimum a **reckless** disregard for whether the statement would be perceived as threatening — i.e., the defendant consciously disregarded a substantial risk that their communication would be received as a threat. Purely negligent threat-making is not sufficient for criminal prosecution.

This matters enormously for online speech. A furious tweet aimed at a public official, an angry comment on a news article, or a heated exchange in a Facebook group can all generate Secret Service or FBI referrals and potentially federal charges. Courts look at context: the platform, the specific words used, whether the message was directed at a specific person, the defendant's history, and whether the recipient was actually placed in fear.

Courts have found § 871 violations for:
- Facebook posts depicting or describing presidential violence
- Letters to the White House describing specific harm
- Voicemails to government offices with explicit death threats
- Social media videos portraying harm to officials

Courts have acquitted or dismissed when statements were clearly political metaphor, literary expression, or when the defendant lacked knowledge that the statement would be perceived as a threat.

## Who Investigates and Prosecutes

**Secret Service** has the primary investigative role for § 871 and § 879 threats against protectees — current and former Presidents, Vice Presidents, candidates, and their families. The Secret Service receives tens of thousands of threat referrals per year and investigates those that meet the true threat threshold.

**FBI** handles threats under § 875 and § 876 that do not involve Secret Service protectees, including threats against members of Congress, judges, and other federal officials.

**U.S. Postal Inspection Service** investigates threatening mail (§ 876) and coordinates with FBI and Secret Service.

Prosecution is handled by U.S. Attorneys' offices, sometimes with support from DOJ's National Security Division for threats with terrorism connections.

## Penalties and Sentencing

Federal threat convictions result in federal prison time and fines. The [Federal Sentencing Guidelines](federal-sentencing-guidelines.md) apply — a first-time offender convicted under § 871 or § 875(c) might face 6–24 months depending on criminal history, while enhancements apply for targeting protected officials, using the internet to amplify reach, or combining threats with other criminal conduct (stalking, harassment, actual violence).

Probation and home detention are possible for low-end cases, but sentences of 12–36 months are not unusual for credible, specific threats with no mental health mitigation.

## How It Affects You

**If you've made or are considering making angry statements about public officials online**: These statutes carry real legal risk for written statements — texts, social media posts, and emails are permanent and recoverable. Intent ("I was just venting") is **not a complete defense** after *Counterman v. Colorado* (2023): the government must show you were subjectively reckless about being understood as a threat, but a post directed at a named individual using language like "someone should hurt" or "deserves to die" meets that standard even if you never intended to act. The safe harbor for pure satire or hyperbole exists but is narrower than most people assume.

**If you receive threatening communications**, you can report them to local law enforcement, the FBI (tips.fbi.gov), the U.S. Postal Inspection Service, or the Secret Service. Threats against federal judges are taken particularly seriously and are aggressively investigated by U.S. Marshals and FBI. See also [Assault on Federal Officers](assault-federal-officers.md) for when threats escalate to physical violence against federal employees, [Obstruction of Justice](obstruction-of-justice.md) for threats targeting judicial or investigative proceedings, and [Federal Domestic Violence & Stalking](federal-domestic-violence-stalking.md) for the interstate stalking framework that often overlaps with § 875.

**If you're a campaign or advocacy organization receiving threats**: A coordinated campaign of threatening communications against candidates, officials, or activists — emails, calls, social media — can constitute conspiracy to make interstate threats under § 875 combined with general conspiracy statutes. Document all threats (screenshots with metadata, call logs), and report to the **FBI (tips.fbi.gov)** and **U.S. Marshals Service** for threats against federal officials. The DOJ Civil Rights Division handles threats targeting protected characteristics. Campaign security firms can assist with threat assessment and protective protocols.

**If you are under investigation**, the true threat doctrine creates viable defenses in some cases — especially where the statement was clearly hyperbolic, made in private conversation, or in an artistic or political context. The Counterman recklessness standard requires proof of the defendant's subjective mental state.

## State Variations

All states have their own threatening communications statutes — typically covering threats to public officials, stalking threats, and general criminal threatening. Federal jurisdiction attaches whenever interstate commerce (phone, email, mail, internet) is involved, which in practice covers virtually every modern threat scenario. Federal and state charges can be filed simultaneously without double jeopardy bar (dual sovereignty doctrine).

## Pending Legislation

Online harassment and threats against election officials and poll workers have received increasing legislative attention. Proposals to strengthen § 875 penalties for coordinated online threat campaigns and to expand § 879 to cover state and local election officials have been introduced in recent Congresses, though none have become law as of 2026.

## Recent Developments

- **2023**: Supreme Court decided **Counterman v. Colorado**, establishing that at minimum a reckless mens rea standard is required under the First Amendment for true threat prosecutions — overturning a lower standard some circuits had used
- **2024–2026**: Significant increase in prosecutions for threats against members of Congress and election officials, driven partly by post-2020 election controversy and the January 6 aftermath
- **AI-generated content**: DOJ has begun addressing AI-generated threatening content (deepfake videos depicting violence against officials) as potentially falling under § 875 when directed at specific individuals with intent to threaten

In April 2025, former FBI Director James Comey was indicted on two federal charges of making threats to harm President Trump, stemming from a social media post in which he arranged seashells spelling "86 47" — a reference widely interpreted as a call to kill the 47th president. Comey denied criminal intent, characterizing the post as a reference to a restaurant term for being out of stock. The case illustrates how § 871 prosecutions can turn on contested questions of intent and context in social media communications. [Source](https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/5854125-comeys-response-to-indictment/)

Former White House attorney Ty Cobb publicly criticized the DOJ's indictment of former FBI Director James Comey as "vindictive prosecution" and "classic revenge," predicting the case would be dismissed. Cobb, who served in Trump's first administration, characterized the charges as "specious" during a media appearance on April 29, 2026. His comments add a notable dissenting legal voice to the Comey prosecution, which centers on contested questions of intent under § 871. [Source](https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/5854505-ty-cobb-james-comey-indictment-trump-administration/)

Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.) publicly condemned the DOJ's indictment of former FBI Director James Comey as "surreal and absurd," adding a prominent congressional Democratic voice to the growing criticism of the prosecution. Raskin's remarks, made on April 29, 2026, follow similar criticism from former White House attorney Ty Cobb, who called the charges "vindictive prosecution." The case, centered on Comey's "86 47" seashell social media post, continues to draw sharp political and legal commentary on both sides. [Source](https://thehill.com/homenews/house/5854544-raskin-calls-comey-indictment-absurd/)

The number "86" is central to the DOJ's indictment of former FBI Director James Comey under § 871, with prosecutors arguing that the Instagram post of seashells spelling "86 47" constituted a threat against President Trump (the 47th president), while Comey maintains the numbers were coincidental or referred to a culinary term meaning "out of stock." The case turns on whether a reasonable person would interpret the arrangement as a serious expression of intent to harm, and what Comey subjectively understood about how the post would be received — the core mens rea question under *Counterman v. Colorado*. [Source](https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/5854539-doj-comey-indictment-86-sea-shells/)

On April 29, 2026, former FBI Director James Comey surrendered to law enforcement and made an initial court appearance in Alexandria, Va., without entering a plea, following his indictment on charges under § 871 related to the "86 47" seashell social media post. The court appearance marks the first formal judicial proceeding in the case. [Source](https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/5854879-james-comey-surrender-trump-doj/)

Rep. Dan Meuser (R-Pa.) publicly defended the DOJ's indictment of former FBI Director James Comey on April 29, 2026, arguing that Comey's "86 47" seashell post constituted dangerous speech, offering a contrasting Republican congressional perspective to Democratic criticism of the prosecution. Meuser noted this is the second time DOJ has sought to prosecute Comey. His remarks add to the growing political commentary surrounding the § 871 case, which continues to turn on contested questions of intent and context in social media communications. [Source](https://thehill.com/homenews/house/5854681-comey-seashells-trump-threat/)

On April 29, 2026, Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche stated that the indictment of former FBI Director James Comey was "not an audition" for the attorney general position and that he was "absolutely, positively not" directed by President Trump to pursue the charges. Blanche's remarks were made in response to criticism that the prosecution was politically motivated. The statement adds a significant DOJ leadership perspective to the ongoing § 871 case centered on Comey's "86 47" seashell social media post. [Source](https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/5854642-james-comey-todd-blanche-indictment-justice-department/)

Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) expressed skepticism about the DOJ's case against former FBI Director James Comey on April 29, 2026, stating he hopes prosecutors have stronger evidence than "just the picture in the sand." Tillis's remarks represent a notable Republican Senate voice questioning the sufficiency of the evidence in the § 871 prosecution centered on Comey's "86 47" seashell social media post. [Source](https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/5855011-thom-tillis-comey-indictment/)

Former Deputy FBI Director Andrew McCabe publicly criticized the DOJ's second indictment of former FBI Director James Comey on April 29, 2026, telling CNN's Anderson Cooper that the department has "real work to do" and that the prosecution "boggles my mind." McCabe's remarks add another prominent former senior FBI official's voice to the growing criticism of the § 871 case centered on Comey's "86 47" seashell social media post. [Source](https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/5854669-mccabe-slams-comey-indictment/)

On May 5, 2026, The Hill reported that Dean DelleChiaie, 35, an FAA contractor in New Hampshire, is facing federal charges after authorities said he threatened to kill President Trump and used a work computer to research previous assassination attempts against the president. He was arrested on a Monday and made his first appearance before a federal judge on the following Tuesday. [Source](https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/5864633-faa-contractor-threatens-trump/)

## Sources
- [Federal Threat Crimes — Threatening the President, Interstate Threats & Threatening Communications on PolicyRisk](https://policyrisk.com/wiki/federal-threat-crimes)

## Related
- [federal anti terrorism law](https://policyrisk.com/wiki/federal-anti-terrorism-law)
- [federal civil rights crimes](https://policyrisk.com/wiki/federal-civil-rights-crimes)
- [federal false statements perjury](https://policyrisk.com/wiki/federal-false-statements-perjury)
- [assault federal officers](https://policyrisk.com/wiki/assault-federal-officers)
- [federal criminal law](https://policyrisk.com/wiki/federal-criminal-law)
- [obstruction of justice](https://policyrisk.com/wiki/obstruction-of-justice)
- [federal kidnapping law](https://policyrisk.com/wiki/federal-kidnapping-law)
- [hobbs act extortion robbery](https://policyrisk.com/wiki/hobbs-act-extortion-robbery)

Source: PRIA, https://policyrisk.com/wiki/federal-threat-crimes (as of 2026-11-15).
