Futures Traders Can't Withdraw if It Leaves Margin Short—Bureaucracy Saves the Day
Published Date: 1/22/2025
Rule
Summary
Starting March 24, 2025, futures commission merchants (FCMs) must stop customers from withdrawing money if it leaves their account short on required margin. Also, FCMs can treat separate accounts of one customer as totally separate for some rules, making things clearer and safer. Big changes kick in by July 21, 2025, for some FCMs, and by January 22, 2026, for the rest—helping protect everyone's trading funds.
Analyzed Economic Effects
4 provisions identified: 2 benefits, 1 costs, 1 mixed.
No Withdrawals That Undermine Margin
Starting March 24, 2025, futures commission merchants (FCMs) must prevent a customer from withdrawing funds if the account balance after the withdrawal would be insufficient to meet the customer's initial margin requirements. Clearing-member FCMs must comply by July 21, 2025, and all other FCMs must comply by January 22, 2026.
Separate-Account Treatment Allowed With Conditions
The rule permits an FCM, if it and the customer affirmatively elect and meet specified requirements, to treat separate accounts of the same customer as accounts of separate entities for certain regulations. Requirements include written internal controls, monitoring accounts on separate and combined bases, disclosure to customers, DSRO notification, capital and risk-management rules, and stopping separate-account disbursements upon specified events and resuming upon cure.
No Cross-Account Portfolio Margining
When an FCM provides separate-account treatment, the rule prohibits applying portfolio margining or cross-margining offsets between separate accounts of the same customer; portfolio margining may still occur within an individual separate account.
Business Day Definition Excludes Saturdays
The rule amends the definition of "business day" so it means any day other than a Saturday, Sunday, or U.S. holiday. This affects timing rules that reference a "one business day" margin call or related deadlines under the final rule.
Personalized for You
How does this regulation affect your finances?
Personalize government policy and PRIA will tell you what this federal register document means for your household, plus every other regulation we track. PRIA reads each provision against your financial profile to show you exactly what matters to your wallet.
Key Dates
Department and Agencies
Related Federal Register Documents
2026-19290, Privacy Act Regulations
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) is reopening the comment period for its proposed Privacy Act rule changes, which affect how insider risk program records are handled. This gives everyone 10 more days, until October 1, 2026, to share their thoughts. No new costs or deadlines beyond this extension are involved, but it’s a key chance to weigh in on privacy protections.
2026-14509, Margin Requirements for Uncleared Swaps for Swap Dealers and Major Swap Participants
Starting August 17, 2026, swap dealers and big swap players get some margin rule relief! New rules say certain new investment funds won’t have to exchange initial margin for up to three years, and more types of money market funds can now count as good collateral. Plus, the rules tweak how much value gets discounted on some assets, making it easier and cheaper to trade uncleared swaps.
2026-05635, Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto Assets and Certain Transactions Involving Crypto Assets
Starting March 23, 2026, the SEC and CFTC are making it clear that some crypto assets and transactions must follow federal securities laws. This means crypto companies and investors need to play by new rules to keep things fair and safe. Expect more transparency and possible costs for compliance as the government steps up oversight in the crypto world.
2026-22889, Agency Information Collection Activities: Notice of Intent To Extend Collection 3038-0026, Gross Collection of Exchange-Set Margins for Omnibus Accounts
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) wants to keep collecting info about how big margins are for omnibus accounts, which are accounts that hold money for lots of traders. They’re asking for public feedback until January 11, 2027, but no big changes or costs are expected—just a smooth extension of current rules. This affects traders and firms handling these accounts, keeping things clear and fair in the trading world.
2026-22890, Agency Information Collection Activities: Notice of Intent To Extend Collection 3038-0015, Copies of Crop and Market Information Reports
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission wants to keep collecting info about crop and market reports and is asking the public for feedback by January 11, 2027. This affects farmers, traders, and anyone interested in crop market data, but there are no new fees or big changes—just a renewal of the current process. It’s your chance to speak up before the paperwork continues!
2026-22863, DCM Impartial Access Requirements
Starting November 10, 2026, designated contract markets (DCMs) must follow clear rules to give everyone fair and open access to trade. This means no playing favorites or blocking traders unfairly, helping markets stay competitive and liquid. If you trade or run a DCM, get ready for these fair access rules that keep trading honest and open for all.
Previous / Next Documents
Previous: 2024-30927, Investment of Customer Funds by Futures Commission Merchants and Derivatives Clearing Organizations
Starting February 21, 2025, futures commission merchants and derivatives clearing organizations must follow new rules on how they invest customer funds. These changes update what investments are allowed, set new limits to keep money safe, and change reporting requirements to the government. The goal? Protect your money better while keeping the market strong and transparent.
Next: 2025-01115, Spectrum Sharing Rules for NGSO Fixed-Satellite Service Systems; Correction
The FCC fixed a small mistake in its rules about how certain satellite companies share space on the airwaves. This update mainly affects companies using non-geostationary satellites for fixed services, delaying one part of the rule until official approval is given. No new costs or deadlines hit right now, but companies should watch for when the delayed rule kicks in.