Federal Researchers Revise the Scorecard for Job Program Studies
Published Date: 5/19/2025
Notice
Summary
The Administration for Children and Families is updating the rules for how they review and rate studies about programs that help people with low incomes find and keep jobs. They want your feedback on these new standards by June 18, 2025. These changes will help states and local agencies pick the best programs to boost employment, making sure taxpayer money is spent wisely.
Analyzed Economic Effects
5 provisions identified: 5 benefits, 0 costs, 0 mixed.
New Standards to Rate Program Cost Studies
If you are a State or local agency deciding which employment programs to fund, the Clearinghouse will use new standards to review three types of cost studies (cost analysis, cost-effectiveness, cost-benefit). Cost studies must meet threshold standards to be rated; those that meet thresholds are scored on 1–3 quality scales that are averaged (rounded to the nearest tenth). Average-score bands are: 1.0–1.5 = "meets standards with low quality," 1.6–2.5 = "meets standards with moderate quality," and 2.6–3.0 = "meets standards with distinction." Studies that fail thresholds receive a rating of "Interpret cost findings with caution."
Clearinghouse Aims to Improve Program Choices
ACF states that Pathways to Work is intended for State and local Temporary Assistance for Needy Families administrators and others to identify services that best help people with low incomes improve employment and earnings, and that the Protocol Version 2.0 revisions (including cost-study standards) are intended to help states and local agencies pick the best programs and make sure taxpayer money is spent wisely.
Baseline Equivalence Via Effect-Size Rules
When a study has a statistically significant baseline difference on a required characteristic, reviewers may compute an effect size. If the effect size is less than 0.05 standard deviations, the baseline equivalence requirement is met; if between 0.05 and 0.25 standard deviations the study must control for the characteristic; if greater than 0.25 standard deviations (or no effect size can be computed), baseline equivalence is not met.
Limited Waiver of 1-Year Baseline Timing Rule
The protocol relaxes the rule that control measures of employment or earnings be taken at least 1 year before an intervention in three limited cases: (1) studies where participants were incarcerated for 1 year or longer before the program began; (2) studies of minor youth who would not have 1 year of prior work history (for example, programs for 16-year-olds); and (3) when authors provide explicit, credible evidence that both groups could not have had a change in earnings in the year prior. Any timing waiver requires approval by the Pathways to Work principal investigator. The exemption applies only to the timing requirement, not to the requirement to control for pre-program differences.
Changes to How Program Effectiveness Is Labeled
The Protocol revises program effectiveness ratings: the "Insufficient Evidence to Assess Support" category now applies only to single-study cases where none of the findings are statistically significant; the "Not Supported" category continues but now explicitly covers two or more studies with a pattern of only null or unfavorable findings; and the prior category "No Evidence to Assess Support" is renamed "Cannot Assess Support."
Personalized for You
How does this regulation affect your finances?
Personalize government policy and PRIA will tell you what this federal register document means for your household, plus every other regulation we track. PRIA reads each provision against your financial profile to show you exactly what matters to your wallet.
Key Dates
Department and Agencies
Related Federal Register Documents
2026-16414, Adoption and Foster Care Analysis and Reporting System
This document withdraws a proposed rule that was published in the Federal Register on January 11, 2008. The proposed rule would have amended the Adoption and Foster Care Analysis and Reporting System (AFCARS) regulations at 45 CFR 1355.40 and the appendices to Part 1355 to modify the requirements for States to collect and report data to ACF on children in out-of-home care and in subsidized adoption or guardianship arrangements with the State. This document also withdraws the provision of the 2008 proposed rule that implemented the AFCARS penalty requirements of the Adoption Promotion Act of 2003 (Pub. L. 108-145).
2026-16134, Reducing Federal Burden for Head Start Programs
This NPRM proposes to rescind and replace the Head Start Program Performance Standards (Performance Standards), last revised in 2024. The proposed Performance Standards would significantly reduce Federal bureaucratic burden on programs; defer to State policies wherever possible; return substantial local control to Head Start agencies delivering the services and to parents as the primary caregivers and decision-makers for their children; reduce unnecessary duplication of Head Start regulations with Federal statute and other regulations; and emphasize the critical role of health, nutrition, and physical exercise for young children.
2026-11530, Employment and Training Services for Noncustodial Parents in the Child Support Program; Rescission
The government plans to cancel a recent rule that let child support agencies offer job training to noncustodial parents using federal funds. This change affects agencies and parents involved in the child support program and could shift how support services are funded and delivered. Comments on this proposal are open until August 10, 2026, so folks have time to weigh in before it’s final.
2026-09383, Restoring Flexibility To Support Head Start Program Access
The government wants to give Head Start programs more freedom by removing some strict rules about staff wages and benefits. This change aims to save over $2 billion and help programs serve more kids better. If you want to share your thoughts, make sure to comment by June 11, 2026!
2026-06632, Work Participation Rate Calculation Changes: Recalibration of the Caseload Reduction Credit and Prohibition of Small Checks in Work Participation Rate Calculation
The government is updating how it measures work participation for families getting help through TANF. They’re changing the base year for counting caseload drops from 2005 to 2015 and won’t count tiny monthly payments under $35 in work rate calculations. These changes, required by a 2023 law, affect states and could impact funding starting soon, so everyone should pay attention and share their thoughts by May 6, 2026.
2026-21186, Submission for Office of Management and Budget Review; Unaccompanied Refugee Minors Program ORR-3 Report and ORR-4 Report
The Office of Refugee Resettlement wants to keep collecting info on unaccompanied refugee kids for three more years but with simpler, clearer forms. This change affects agencies helping these kids by cutting paperwork by about 41% and switching outcome reports from youth to providers. Comments on these updates are open until November 16, 2026, with a year to fully roll out the new forms.
Previous / Next Documents
Previous: 2025-08841, Agency Information Collection Activities; Wildlife Video Data Scoring
The U.S. Geological Survey wants to keep collecting info on wildlife videos to help study animals better. They’re asking for public feedback by July 18, 2025, to make sure this data collection is useful and not too much work. This renewal won’t cost you money but helps scientists keep tracking wildlife in smart ways.
Next: 2025-08843, Self-Regulatory Organizations; Cboe EDGX Exchange, Inc.; Notice of Filing and Immediate Effectiveness of a Proposed Rule Change To Amend Its Fee Schedule by Revising the Shares Component Applicable to Add/Remove Volume Tiers 1-3
Cboe EDGX Exchange is updating its fee schedule by changing how shares count toward volume discounts in Tiers 1-3. This affects traders who add or remove shares on the exchange and could impact their fees starting immediately. The goal is to keep fees fair and competitive in a busy market.