Underground Miners Could Use More Respirators Without Special Permission
Published Date: 7/1/2025
Proposed Rule
Summary
MSHA wants to make it easier for underground mine workers to use Powered Air Purifying Respirators (PAPRs) that aren’t officially approved but still safe when used right. This means mine operators won’t have to ask for special permission every time they want to use these respirators, saving time and hassle. Comments on this change are open until July 31, 2025, so speak up if you have thoughts!
Analyzed Economic Effects
7 provisions identified: 4 benefits, 3 costs, 0 mixed.
PAPR Purchase Estimates
MSHA estimates that over a 10-year period each underground MNM mine would purchase 10 PAPRs and each underground coal mine would purchase 50 PAPRs at $3,000 per PAPR, resulting in a 10-year equipment purchase total of $36.0 million (undiscounted).
Use PAPRs Without Filing Petitions
MSHA proposes to allow non-permissible Powered Air Purifying Respirators (PAPRs) to be used in specified underground areas of mines without mine operators filing petitions for modification. The proposal affects about 197 underground metal/nonmetal (MNM) mines and 215 underground coal mines and comments are due July 31, 2025.
Continuous Methane Monitoring Obligations
The proposed rule would require a competent person (MNM) or qualified person (coal) to continuously monitor for methane when non-permissible PAPRs are in use, require methane detectors that meet certain requirements, and require immediate de-energizing and removal of PAPRs if a specified methane percentage is detected. MSHA estimates methane-monitoring labor costs of $13.1 million over 10 years.
Avoided Petition Filing Costs
MSHA estimates that by removing the need to file petitions for PAPRs, mine operators would avoid petition-related costs totaling $20.47 million (undiscounted) over 10 years. MSHA gives annualized avoided cost estimates of $2.05 million at 0% discount, $2.25 million at 3%, and $2.52 million at 7%.
Certification Requirement for PAPRs
Non-permissible PAPRs used under the rule must be certified to ANSI/UL 60079-11 (Standard for Explosive Atmospheres--Part 11) and certification must be performed by organizations recognized under OSHA's Nationally Recognized Testing Laboratory (NRTL) program. MSHA would incorporate by reference ANSI/UL 60079-11 (including revisions through September 14, 2018) and seven other related voluntary consensus standards.
Reduced Paperwork and Small-Business Finding
Under the proposed rule, annual petitions concerning PAPRs would drop by 26 (from 46 to 20 per year), reducing respondents, responses, burden hours, and recordkeeping costs. MSHA estimates affected respondents drop to 20, responses to 68, burden hours to 649, and recordkeeping costs to $11,735; MSHA also preliminarily certifies the rule would not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small entities (total annualized cost $4.93 million vs. $49.1 billion in affected sector revenue; impact = 0.010%).
No Change to Core Safety Standards
MSHA states the proposed rule would not change existing ventilation requirements, methane monitoring requirements, de-energization requirements, or rock-dusting requirements, and the Agency preliminarily determined the proposal would not reduce existing protections for miners.
Personalized for You
How does this regulation affect your finances?
Personalize government policy and PRIA will tell you what this federal register document means for your household, plus every other regulation we track. PRIA reads each provision against your financial profile to show you exactly what matters to your wallet.
Key Dates
Department and Agencies
Related Federal Register Documents
2026-15670, Roof Control Plan Approval Criteria
In response to a public request, the Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) is reopening the rulemaking record and is scheduling a virtual public hearing on the Agency's proposed rule published on July 1, 2025, titled, "Roof Control Plan Approval Criteria."
2026-15717, Ventilation Plan Approval Criteria
In response to a public request, the Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) is reopening the rulemaking record and is scheduling a virtual public hearing on the Agency's proposed rule published on July 1, 2025, titled, "Ventilation Plan Approval Criteria."
2026-10456, Department of Labor Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act Annual Adjustments for 2026
Good news for businesses and workers: the Department of Labor won’t raise any fines or penalties in 2026 because the usual inflation data wasn’t available. This means all civil penalties stay the same starting May 27, 2026. So, no surprise cost hikes this year—just steady rules and steady fees!
2026-21213, Affirmative Decisions on Petitions for Modification Granted in Whole or in Part
Mine operators and miners can ask MSHA to change safety rules if they have a safer or equally safe way to work. Between January and June 2026, MSHA approved some of these requests, letting mines use new methods that keep workers just as safe. These changes might include new equipment or procedures, and details are available online or by contacting MSHA.
2026-21175, Petition for Modification of Application of Existing Mandatory Safety Standards
Panther Creek Mining, LLC is asking to change some safety rules at their mine to use a different method that keeps miners just as safe. This petition could affect how safety standards are applied at their site and might save time or money without risking anyone’s safety. If you want to share your thoughts, you need to comment by November 16, 2026.
2026-21174, Petition for Modification of Application of Existing Mandatory Safety Standards
Panther Creek Mining, LLC is asking to change some safety rules at their mine to use a different method that keeps miners just as safe. This petition could affect how safety standards are applied at their site and might save time or money without risking anyone’s safety. Comments on this request must be sent by November 16, 2026, so everyone has a chance to weigh in.
Previous / Next Documents
Previous: 2025-11741, Electronic Surveying Equipment in Underground Mines
MSHA wants to let underground coal mines use electronic surveying tools in dangerous areas without extra paperwork, as long as the gear meets safety rules. This change helps mine operators save time and effort while keeping miners safe with better maps. Comments on this proposal are open until July 31, 2025.
Next: 2025-11845, Rescission of Affirmative Outreach Requirements for Recipients of WIOA Title I Financial Assistance
The Department of Labor is planning to remove the rule that requires organizations getting WIOA Title I funds to do special outreach to certain groups. This change affects anyone receiving this financial help and means less paperwork and rules to follow. Comments on this change are open until July 31, 2025, and there’s no direct impact on funding amounts.