DHS Takes Over Immigration Penalties in a Federal Handoff
Published Date: 6/27/2025
Rule
Summary
Starting June 27, 2025, the government is changing how it handles fines for certain immigration rule breakers. Now, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) will be the only agency issuing and handling appeals for these civil penalties, instead of the Department of Justice. This affects people who don’t leave when they’re supposed to or try to enter the U.S. illegally, making the process faster and clearer.
Analyzed Economic Effects
7 provisions identified: 0 benefits, 6 costs, 1 mixed.
DHS now issues and hears appeals for fines
If you face a civil monetary penalty for failing to depart, willfully failing to depart after a final removal order, or improper entry, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) — not the Department of Justice's Board of Immigration Appeals — will issue the fines and handle appeals starting June 27, 2025.
Voluntary-departure fines range $1,992–$9,970
If you were granted voluntary departure but fail to leave during the allowed period, you can be fined between $1,992 and $9,970 (amounts adjusted for inflation as described in the rule).
Failure-to-depart fines up to $998 per day
If you are subject to a final removal order and willfully fail or refuse to depart, the statute provides a civil penalty of not more than $500 per day, which the Departments note is $998 after inflation adjustment.
Procedure changes to speed up fines and collections
The rule streamlines procedures so DHS can impose these penalties more quickly and at scale: DHS states it will move away from lengthy BIA appeals and existing 8 CFR part 280 procedures (citing a BIA backlog of 160,098 pending appeals) so penalties can be issued and collections started faster. The Departments explicitly say this change is intended to allow DHS to impose more civil penalties more quickly and in proportion to the number of people who have unlawfully entered or failed to depart; ICE had initiated nearly 10,000 Notices of Intention to Fine as of June 13, 2025.
Unlawful-entry fines of $100–$500 per entry
If you are apprehended entering or attempting to enter improperly, you can be fined at least $100 and up to $500 for each entry or attempted entry (amounts adjusted for inflation); repeat violations are subject to twice the amount for subsequent offenses.
Service, response window, and interview procedure changes
The Departments state the IFR replaces personal or certified-mail service, a 30‑day response period, and routine in‑person interviews with routine mail service and shorter, written-only challenge procedures for these particular penalties so DHS can resolve disputes without in‑person hearings.
Where collected fines are deposited and used
The rule notes that penalties are deposited into the Immigration Enforcement Account, Border and Transportation Security, and those funds may be used to support DHS activities such as identifying, investigating, detaining and removing criminal aliens and for repair, maintenance, and construction of barriers.
Personalized for You
How does this regulation affect your finances?
Personalize government policy and PRIA will tell you what this federal register document means for your household, plus every other regulation we track. PRIA reads each provision against your financial profile to show you exactly what matters to your wallet.
Key Dates
Department and Agencies
Related Federal Register Documents
2026-21024, Imposition and Collection of Civil Penalties for Certain Immigration-Related Violations
Starting October 14, 2026, people who break certain immigration rules—like not leaving when they’re supposed to or trying to enter the U.S. illegally—can face fines more easily. The government made it simpler to collect these penalties but will now accept late appeals if mail delays beyond a person’s control caused the delay. This change affects immigrants and could mean quicker fines or chances to appeal if timing issues happen.
2025-23970, Security Bars and Processing; Confirmation of Effective Date; Partial Withdrawal
Starting December 31, 2025, new rules about when someone can’t get asylum because they might be a public health risk will kick in. Some parts of a 2020 rule are being pulled back to keep things clear, but the main health-related changes stay. This affects people applying for asylum and could speed up how their cases are handled.
2026-15458, Civil Money Penalty for Actions in Contempt of an Immigration Judge's Proper Exercise of Authority
This notice of proposed rulemaking ("NPRM") would implement a provision of the Immigration and Nationality Act ("INA" or "the Act") that authorizes Immigration Judges, under regulations prescribed by the Attorney General, to sanction by civil money penalty any action (or inaction) in contempt of the proper exercise of their authority by certain individuals. The rule would: define the scope of the contempt authority; provide procedures for contempt findings, penalty determinations, and penalty payment; establish an appellate process; and implement oversight of the use of contempt authority. The rule would also make conforming changes to the grounds for practitioner discipline.
2026-10082, Increasing the Fee for Certain Aliens Ordered Removed in Absentia as Established by the HR-1 Reconciliation Bill
The government plans to raise the fee from $5,130 to $18,000 for certain people who were ordered to leave the U.S. but didn’t and got caught later. This change affects those removed in absentia and includes yearly inflation updates to keep the fee current. Comments on this proposal are open until June 22, 2026, so now’s the time to speak up!
2026-21765, Agency Information Collection Activities: ICE FOIA Request Form, I-902
ICE is introducing a new FOIA Request Form (I-902) to make it easier and faster for people to ask for government records. This form helps ICE verify who’s asking and what info they want, so they can follow the rules and keep things organized. If you want to comment on this change, you’ve got until December 28, 2026, and there’s no cost to use the form.
2026-21683, Agency Information Collection Activities: Extension of a Currently Approved Collection: Electronic Bonds Online (eBonds) Access
ICE is extending the approval for their Electronic Bonds Online (eBonds) system, fixing some earlier mistakes about how much time it takes to use. They’re asking the public for feedback until November 23, 2026. This update won’t cost extra money but helps keep the system running smoothly for those who use it.
Previous / Next Documents
Previous: 2025-11922, Safety Zones; Annual Fireworks Displays Within the Captain of the Port, Puget Sound Area of Responsibility
The Coast Guard is stepping up to keep everyone safe during the annual fireworks shows around Puget Sound by enforcing special safety zones on the water. If you're boating in these areas on the event dates, you’ll need to follow the Coast Guard’s directions or risk getting in trouble. These rules kick in during specific times in early July, so plan ahead and enjoy the show safely!
Next: 2025-11446, Standards of Performance for New Stationary Sources and Emission Guidelines for Existing Sources: Other Solid Waste Incineration Units Review
The EPA just updated the rules for solid waste incinerators, which are facilities that burn trash to reduce waste. These changes affect new and existing incinerators by tightening pollution controls, improving monitoring, and clarifying startup and shutdown rules. The new rules kick in on August 29, 2025, helping protect air quality without causing big cost shocks for operators.