Railroads Ditch Old Rules: STB Pushes Fairer Competition Ahead
Published Date: 1/9/2026
Proposed Rule
Summary
The Surface Transportation Board wants to scrap old rules that limit how rail companies compete with each other. This change lets the Board decide on special rail deals case-by-case, making competition fairer and more flexible. Rail companies and shippers should watch for comments due by March 10, 2026, with no immediate cost changes expected.
Analyzed Economic Effects
5 provisions identified: 4 benefits, 0 costs, 1 mixed.
Repeal of Part 1144 Restores Board Discretion
The Surface Transportation Board proposes to repeal 49 CFR part 1144 and, instead, consider prescriptions of through routes, through rates, and reciprocal switching on a case-by-case basis under 49 U.S.C. 10705 and 11102(c). Comments on the proposed repeal are due by March 10, 2026, with reply comments due April 24, 2026.
Anticompetitive Conduct Test Removed
The Board proposes to eliminate part 1144's requirement that petitioners show 'anticompetitive conduct' as a prerequisite for prescribing reciprocal switching or through routes. The Board states that the anticompetitive-conduct standard has operated as a high barrier to relief for shippers.
Standing/Use Thresholds May Be Eliminated
The Board proposes to remove part 1144's requirement that petitioners show they have used or would use a through route or reciprocal switch for a 'significant portion' of their transportation needs. The Board expresses concern that the standing/use requirement could lock out small businesses from seeking competitive-access relief.
Case-by-Case Adjudication Instead of Rule
If part 1144 is repealed, the Board would decide requests for reciprocal switching, through routes, and through rates on a case-by-case basis under 49 U.S.C. 10705(b) and 11102(c), allowing the Board to weigh factors like carrier revenue needs, operational feasibility, and current rail operations in individual cases.
Limits on Product/Geographic Evidence Lifted
The Board proposes to drop part 1144's restrictions that limited consideration of product and geographic competition in prescription proceedings. The Board says it anticipates generally excluding such evidence in rate proceedings but that parties could present it in individual adjudications if timely indicated.
Your PRIA Score
Personalized for You
How does this regulation affect your finances?
Sign up for a PRIA Policy Scan to see your personalized alignment score for this federal register document and every other regulation we track. We analyze your financial profile against policy provisions to show you exactly what matters to your wallet.
Key Dates
Department and Agencies
Related Federal Register Documents
2026-11901 — 60-Day Notice of Intent To Seek Extension of Approval of Collection: Recordations (Rail and Water Carrier Liens), Water Carrier Tariffs, and Agricultural Contract Summaries
The Surface Transportation Board wants to keep collecting info about rail and water carrier liens, water carrier tariffs, and agricultural contract summaries—just like they’ve been doing, with no changes. This affects big railroads and water carriers who file these records, and they’re asking for your thoughts by August 11, 2026. No new fees or extra paperwork, just a smooth extension to keep things running.
2026-11831 — Kean Burenga and Chesapeake and Delaware, LLC-Continuance in Control Exemption-Delaware and South Branch Railroad, LLC
Kean Burenga and Chesapeake and Delaware, LLC are keeping control of Delaware and South Branch Railroad as it becomes a new Class III rail carrier in New Jersey. This move lets DSBR lease and operate nearly 32 miles of rail lines from two other local railroads, starting soon. No big money changes are expected, but it’s a smart shuffle to keep things running smoothly in the region’s rail network.
2026-11832 — Reliant Transportation Group, LLC, TIP MNC Acquisition, LLC, TIP MN Investments LP, and Tiger Infrastructure Partners Fund IV AIV LP-Acquisition of Control-Southwest Coaches, Inc. and Minnesota Motor Bus, Inc.
Reliant Transportation Group and its partners want to take control of two bus companies, Southwest Coaches and Minnesota Motor Bus, by buying them from the current owners. The government is giving a thumbs-up to this deal unless someone objects by July 27, 2026. If all goes well, the change will happen quickly, but no money details were shared yet.
2026-11833 — Delaware and South Branch Railroad, LLC-Lease and Change of Operator Exemption-Black River & Western Corp. d/b/a Black River & Western Railroad, and Belvidere & Delaware River Railway Company, Inc.
Delaware and South Branch Railroad, LLC (DSBR) is taking over the lease and operation of about 32 miles of rail lines from Black River & Western Railroad and Belvidere & Delaware River Railway. This means DSBR will replace BDR as the operator on a key segment, starting on or after June 28, 2026. The change won’t cost more than $5 million in revenue and won’t limit future rail connections.
2026-11659 — R.J. Corman Railroad Company/Cleveland Line-Lease and Operation Exemption With Interchange Commitment-CSX Transportation, Inc.
R.J. Corman Railroad Company is renewing its lease to run trains on a 15-mile track in Ohio, from Uhrichsville to Dover, that it leases from CSX Transportation. They’ve updated their agreement to keep things rolling smoothly, including a promise to interchange freight with CSX. This deal won’t bring in more than $5 million a year, so it’s a steady, local move with no big money shake-ups.
2026-11395 — 2025 Tax Information for Use in the Revenue Shortfall Allocation Method
The Surface Transportation Board is sharing the 2025 state tax rates for big railroads to help figure out fair shipping prices. These updated tax numbers affect Class I railroads and will be used to check if their rates are reasonable. If you’re involved with rail shipping, keep an eye out—these changes could impact costs starting in 2025.
Previous / Next Documents
Previous: 2026-00215 — Clean Air Act Title V Operating Permit Program Revision; District of Columbia
The EPA is proposing to approve updates to Washington, DC’s air pollution permit program fees to keep it running smoothly and well-funded. They also tidied up some rules without changing their meaning. If you’re a business in DC that needs these permits, watch out for the comment deadline on February 9, 2026—this could affect your fees soon!
Next: 2026-00247 — Airworthiness Directives; Airbus Helicopters
If you own or operate an Airbus H160-B helicopter, heads up! The FAA wants you to replace the emergency life raft system’s gas cylinder container because it might leak due to a design gap. You can’t install the old part anymore unless it meets new safety rules, and comments on this proposal are open until February 23, 2026. This fix keeps everyone safer without breaking the bank.