§14502a — Title 10 Armed Forces | U.S. Code

Summary

If the head of a military service learns there is credible bad information about someone a promotion board picked for promotion to a grade up to major general (or rear admiral in the Navy), the head must call a special review board to re-check that person and decide if the promotion recommendation should stand. The person’s name is taken off public promotion lists and is not sent forward for appointment or nomination while the review happens. The special review board must follow the usual rules for these boards. It looks at the file given to the original promotion board and any new adverse information. The person must be shown that adverse information and given a chance to respond, unless the information is classified—in which case the person gets a suitable summary when possible. If the person already saw the information and gave comments to the first board, new comments may not be required. The review board compares the person’s record to samples of officers who were and were not recommended, without revealing who triggered the review. To keep the promotion recommendation, the person must rank in the top half of the board’s list or be judged better than the best non-selected sample and comparable to those who were recommended. A majority vote is needed to keep the recommendation. If the board does not keep it, the person is treated as not selected. The board sends a signed written report of those it would keep. If the report is approved by the President, the person is appointed as soon as practical with the same seniority, pay start date, and reserve status they would have had from the original recommendation. The Secretary of Defense must make uniform rules for how these reviews work; service-specific extras need the Secretary of Defense’s written approval. Promotion board — the regular selection board that recommended the person.

Title 10, §14502a

Armed Forces — Source: USLM XML via OLRC

(a)(1)If the Secretary of the military department concerned determines that a person recommended by a promotion board for promotion to a grade at or below the grade of major general or rear admiral in the Navy is the subject of credible information of an adverse nature, including any substantiated adverse finding or conclusion described in section 14107(a)(3)(A) of this title, that was not furnished to the promotion board during its consideration of the person for promotion as otherwise required by such section, the Secretary shall convene a special selection review board under this section to review the person and recommend whether the recommendation for promotion of the person should be sustained.

(2)If a person and the recommendation for promotion of the person is subject to review under this section by a special selection review board convened under this section, the name of the person—

(A)shall not be disseminated or publicly released on the list of officers recommended for promotion by the promotion board recommending the promotion of the person; and

(B)shall not be forwarded for appointment or nomination to the Secretary of Defense, the President, or the Senate, as applicable.

(b)(1)Any special selection review board convened under this section shall be convened in accordance with the provisions of section 14502(b)(2) of this title.

(2)Any special selection review board convened under this section may review such number of persons, and recommendations for promotion of such persons, as the Secretary of the military department concerned shall specify in convening such special selection review board.

(c)(1)In reviewing a person and recommending whether the recommendation for promotion of the person should be sustained under this section, a special selection review board convened under this section shall be furnished and consider the following:

(A)The record and information concerning the person furnished in accordance with section 14107(a)(2) of this title to the promotion board that recommended the person for promotion.

(B)Any credible information of an adverse nature on the person, including any substantiated adverse finding or conclusion from an officially documented investigation or inquiry described in section 14107(a)(3)(A) of this title.

(2)The furnishing of information to a special selection review board under paragraph (1)(B) shall be governed by the standards and procedures referred to in paragraph (3)(B) of section 14107(a) of this title applicable to the furnishing of information described in paragraph (3)(A) of such section to promotion boards in accordance with that section.

(3)(A)Before information on person described in paragraph (1)(B) is furnished to a special selection review board for purposes of this section, the Secretary of the military department concerned shall ensure that—

(i)such information is made available to the person; and

(ii)subject to subparagraphs (C) and (D), the person is afforded a reasonable opportunity to submit comments on such information to the special selection review board before its review of the person and the recommendation for promotion of the person under this section.

(B)If information on an officer described in paragraph (1)(B) is not made available to the person as otherwise required by subparagraph (A)(i) due to the classification status of such information, the person shall, to the maximum extent practicable, be furnished a summary of such information appropriate to the person’s authorization for access to classified information.

(C)(i)An opportunity to submit comments on information is not required for a person under subparagraph (A)(ii) if—

(I)such information was made available to the person in connection with the furnishing of such information under section 14107(a) of this title to the promotion board that recommended the promotion of the person subject to review under this section; and

(II)the person submitted comments on such information to that promotion board.

(ii)The comments on information of a person described in clause (i)(II) shall be furnished to the special selection review board.

(D)A person may waive either or both of the following:

(i)The right to submit comments to a special selection review board under subparagraph (A)(ii).

(ii)The furnishing of comments to a special selection review board under subparagraph (C)(ii).

(d)(1)In considering the record and information on a person under this section, the special selection review board shall compare such record and information with an appropriate sampling of the records of those officers of the same competitive category who were recommended for promotion by the promotion board that recommended the person for promotion, and an appropriate sampling of the records of those officers who were considered by and not recommended for promotion by that promotion board.

(2)Records and information shall be presented to a special selection review board for purposes of paragraph (1) in a manner that does not indicate or disclose the person or persons for whom the special selection review board was convened.

(3)In considering whether the recommendation for promotion of a person should be sustained under this section, a special selection review board shall, to the greatest extent practicable, apply standards used by the promotion board that recommended the person for promotion.

(4)The recommendation for promotion of a person may be sustained under this section only if the special selection review board determines that the person—

(A)ranks in the upper half of an order of merit created by the special selection review board or ranks on an order of merit created by the special selection review board as better qualified for promotion than the sample officer highest on the order of merit list who was considered by and not recommended for promotion by the promotion board concerned; and

(B)is comparable in qualification for promotion to those sample officers who were recommended for promotion by that promotion board.

(5)A recommendation for promotion of a person may be sustained under this section only by a vote of a majority of the members of the special selection review board.

(6)If a special selection review board does not sustain a recommendation for promotion of a person under this section, the person shall be considered to have failed of selection for promotion.

(e)(1)Each special selection review board convened under this section shall submit to the Secretary of the military department concerned a written report, signed by each member of the board, containing the name of each person whose recommendation for promotion it recommends for sustainment and certifying that the board has carefully considered the record and information of each person whose name was referred to it.

(2)The provisions of section 14109(c), 14110, and 14111 of this title apply to the report and proceedings of a special selection review board convened under this section in the same manner as they apply to the report and proceedings of a promotion board convened under section 14101(a) of this title.

(f)(1)If the report of a special selection review board convened under this section recommends the sustainment of the recommendation for promotion to the next higher grade of a person whose name was referred to it for review under this section, and the President approves the report, the person shall, as soon as practicable, be appointed to that grade in accordance with section 14308 of this title.

(2)A person who is appointed to the next higher grade as described in paragraph (1) shall, upon that appointment, have the same date of rank, the same effective date for the pay and allowances of that grade, and the same position on the reserve active-status list as the person would have had pursuant to the original recommendation for promotion of the promotion board concerned.

(g)(1)The Secretary of Defense shall prescribe regulations to carry out this section. Such regulations shall apply uniformly across the military departments.

(2)Any regulation prescribed by the Secretary of a military department to supplement the regulations prescribed pursuant to paragraph (1) may not take effect without the approval of the Secretary of Defense, in writing.

(h)In this section, the term “promotion board” means a selection board convened by the Secretary of a military department under section 14101(a) of this title.

Notes & Related Subsidiaries

Editorial Notes

Amendments

2024—Subsec. (d)(4)(A). Pub. L. 118–159 inserted “ranks in the upper half of an order of merit created by the special selection review board or” before “ranks on an order of merit created by the special selection review board as better qualified”. 2023—Subsec. (a)(2)(B). Pub. L. 118–31 amended subpar. (B) generally. Prior to amendment, subpar. (B) read as follows: “shall not be forwarded to the Secretary of Defense, the President, or the Senate, as applicable, or included on a promotion list under section 14308(a) of this title.”

§14502a Special Selection Review Boards

Summary

Title 10, §14502a

Notes & Related Subsidiaries

Editorial Notes

Amendments

Citations & Metadata