New YorkS 38762025-2026 Regular SessionSenate

Requires comparison of prices charged by energy services companies

Sponsored By: Brad Hoylman-Sigal (Democratic)

Signed by Governor

CONSUMER PROTECTIONENERGY

Personalized for You

How does this bill affect your finances?

Personalize government policy and PRIA will tell you what this bill means for your household, plus every other piece of legislation we track. PRIA reads each provision against your financial profile to show you exactly what matters to your wallet.

Bill Overview

Analyzed Economic Effects

1 provisions identified: 1 benefits, 0 costs, 0 mixed.

Clearer price comparisons for energy customers

Starting 180 days after the law became law, energy services companies (ESCOs) must give customers regular price comparisons. Each bill’s first page must compare the prior billing period’s energy supply and delivery prices side by side. It must show ESCO prices and what the customer would have paid the local utility or municipality. Charges for energy-related extras must be listed separately. Every 12 months, customers must also receive a comparison covering the prior 12 months. It compares ESCO supply, delivery, and extras with the local utility or municipality’s supply and delivery prices. It must clearly say whether the customer saved money or paid more. The attorney general can sue on its own or following a referral from the listed energy regulators or department. Courts can order penalties up to $1,000 per violation, restitution, costs, and reasonable attorney’s fees. People harmed by a violation can sue to stop it, recover actual damages or $500, whichever is greater, or both. For willful or knowing violations, courts can increase damages to three times actual damages, capped at $10,000. Winning plaintiffs can also receive reasonable attorney’s fees. The Public Service Commission and Long Island Power Authority retain power to limit, suspend, or revoke an ESCO’s selling eligibility. They can also adopt consistent marketing guidelines for residential and commercial customers. Implementing rules can be adopted, changed, or repealed immediately, before the law’s effective date.

Sponsors & Cosponsors

Sponsor

  • Brad Hoylman-Sigal

    Democratic • Senate

Cosponsors

  • Lea Webb

    Democratic • Senate

  • Rachel May

    Democratic • Senate

Roll Call Votes

All Roll Calls

Yes: 198 • No: 15

House vote • 4/30/2025

Assembly floor vote

Yes: 134 • No: 11

Senate vote • 2/25/2025

FLOOR Vote

Yes: 57 • No: 4

committee vote • 2/11/2025

Consumer Protection Committee Vote

Yes: 7 • No: 0

Actions Timeline

  1. APPROVAL MEMO.65

    12/19/2025Senate
  2. SIGNED CHAP.685

    12/19/2025Senate
  3. DELIVERED TO GOVERNOR

    12/8/2025Senate
  4. RETURNED TO SENATE

    4/30/2025House
  5. PASSED ASSEMBLY

    4/30/2025House
  6. ORDERED TO THIRD READING CAL.74

    4/1/2025House
  7. SUBSTITUTED FOR A3875

    4/1/2025House
  8. REFERRED TO ENERGY

    2/25/2025House
  9. DELIVERED TO ASSEMBLY

    2/25/2025Senate
  10. PASSED SENATE

    2/25/2025Senate
  11. ADVANCED TO THIRD READING

    2/24/2025Senate
  12. 2ND REPORT CAL.

    2/12/2025Senate
  13. 1ST REPORT CAL.319

    2/11/2025Senate
  14. REFERRED TO CONSUMER PROTECTION

    1/30/2025Senate

Bill Text

  • Original

    1/30/2025

Related Bills

Back to State Legislation